Istanbul Convention
Introduction
On 3 July 2018, the Chamber of Deputies adopted the bill approving the Council of Europe Convention on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence (Istanbul Convention). It is the first legally binding international convention which, through its integrated and multidisciplinary approach and its gender perspective, covers all forms of violence against women and girls.
The Convention is based on the idea that violence against women and girls is a form of gender-based violence, in that it is committed against women because they are women. It is the State's obligation to tackle this violence effectively in all its forms, by taking measures to prevent it, protecting victims and prosecuting perpetrators; otherwise it is at fault.
Luxembourg is not starting from scratch: well before parliament ratified the Istanbul Convention, it had set up an effective legal framework for victims of violence, in particular victims of domestic violence. In addition, the Ministry of Gender Equality and Diversity regularly runs information, prevention and awareness campaigns on violence against women, often in cooperation with non-governmental organisations.
Implementing the Istanbul Convention is the starting point
to adapt our legislation through the Law of 20 July 2018 approving the Council of Europe Convention on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence, signed in Istanbul on 11 May 2011;
- to raise awareness among both professionals and the general public of all aspects of violence against women and girls;
- to provide information about the help and support network and to improve access to it and its quality;
- to bring together and involve all public and non-public actors in the fight against violence against women and girls;
- to expand the help and support available to victims.
While the Convention focuses particularly on all forms of violence against women, it explicitly recognises that domestic violence and other forms of violence also affect male victims. That is why the Convention encourages States to apply it to male victims too.
The Convention in brief
Preventing violence against women and domestic violence saves lives and reduces human suffering. Governments that agree to be bound by the Convention must take the following measures:
train professionals who are in close contact with victims;
regularly run awareness-raising campaigns;
include topics such as gender equality and non-violent conflict resolution in interpersonal relationships in teaching materials;
set up treatment programmes for perpetrators of domestic violence and for sex offenders;
work closely with NGOs;
involve the media and the private sector in eliminating gender stereotypes and promoting mutual respect.
Preventing this violence must not be the responsibility of States alone. In fact, the Convention calls on all members of society to help create a Europe free from all forms of violence against women and domestic violence. This violence is widespread because misogyny persists. Each of us can, at our own level, challenge gender stereotypes, harmful traditional practices and discrimination against women. Only by achieving real equality between women and men can violence against women be ended.
When preventive measures fail and violence occurs, it is important to provide protection and support to victims and witnesses. This requires intervention and protection by the police, as well as specialist support services such as shelters and counselling services. It is also necessary to ensure that general social services understand the reality and problems of victims of these types of violence and help them to rebuild and resume their lives. Some examples of measures recommended by the Convention:
Ensure access to relevant information. Victims are usually traumatised after an episode of violence and must have easy access to clear, concise information about the services available to them, in a language they understand.
Set up sufficient numbers of easily accessible shelters spread across the country. Victims come from a wide range of social backgrounds. For example, shelters must be just as accessible to women from rural areas or women with disabilities as to women living in urban areas.
Set up easily accessible rape crisis and sexual violence referral centres: these centres provide immediate medical advice, trauma care and forensic services. They are extremely rare in Europe, so it is important to make them widely available.
Let us remember that it is not enough to set up protection structures and support services for victims. We must also make sure that victims are informed of their rights and know where and how to get help.
The Convention defines and criminalises the various forms of violence against women as well as domestic violence. This is one of its many merits. To give effect to it, States Parties may need to introduce new offences, including: psychological and physical violence, sexual violence and rape, stalking, female genital mutilation, forced marriage, forced abortion and forced sterilisation. In addition, States Parties must ensure that culture, tradition or so-called “honour” are not regarded as justifications for such behaviour.
Once these new offences have been introduced into national legal systems, there is no longer any reason not to prosecute perpetrators of violence. On the contrary, States Parties will take a whole range of measures to ensure that every allegation of violence is effectively investigated. Law enforcement agencies will therefore have to respond to calls for help, collect evidence and assess the risk of violence in order to protect the victim properly.
In addition, States Parties must guarantee that victims' rights are respected at all stages of the proceedings and that victims are spared any secondary victimisation.
The Convention is based on the principle that no single body can deal with violence against women and domestic violence on its own. An effective response to this type of violence requires concerted action by many actors. The Convention therefore asks States Parties to implement comprehensive and coordinated policies involving government agencies, NGOs, parliaments and national, regional and local authorities. The aim is for prevention and response policies to be implemented at all levels of government and by all relevant bodies and institutions. This can be done, for example, by drawing up a national action plan that gives each body a specific task or role.
The experience of countries that have already taken this approach shows that much better results are achieved when law enforcement, the justice system, NGOs, child protection agencies and other relevant partners join forces on a given case.
The Convention is not only addressed to governments, non-governmental organisations, national parliaments and local authorities; it also sends a clear message to society as a whole. Every man, woman, boy and girl, every parent and every partner must learn that violence, in whatever form, is not the right answer to difficulties, nor a way to live a peaceful life. Everyone must understand that violence against women and domestic violence are not, and will no longer be, tolerated.
The monitoring mechanism of the Istanbul Convention aims to assess and improve the implementation of the Convention by the Parties. It consists of two separate but interacting bodies:
a group of independent experts, the Group of Experts on Action against Violence against Women and Domestic Violence (GREVIO), initially made up of 10 members and enlarged to 15 members after the 25th ratification. GREVIO's task is to monitor the implementation of the Convention by the Parties. Where appropriate, GREVIO may also adopt general recommendations on themes and concepts relating to the Convention.
a political body, the Committee of the Parties, made up of representatives of the Parties to the Istanbul Convention. The Committee of the Parties follows up on GREVIO's reports and conclusions and adopts recommendations addressed to the Parties concerned. It is also responsible for electing the members of GREVIO.
Violence against women and domestic violence cannot be tackled without addressing gender equality. Women can be victims of violence because of their sex. Certain types of violence, in particular domestic violence, affect women disproportionately.
The Convention therefore places the elimination of violence against women and domestic violence within the objective of de jure and de facto equality. In its preamble, it recognises the structural nature of such violence, which is both a cause and a consequence of unequal power relations between women and men and which prevents women from fully flourishing. To combat inequality, the Convention asks States to implement policies for equality between women and men and to promote the empowerment of women. The aim is not to treat women as helpless victims but to give them the ability to rebuild their lives.
While the Convention focuses particularly on all forms of violence against women, including domestic violence, it also recognises that domestic violence affects male victims too. States may choose whether or not to apply the Convention to boys and men who are victims of violence.
Many forms of discrimination, harmful practices and gender stereotypes form the breeding ground for violent behaviour. That is why the Convention pays particular attention to gender stereotypes in awareness-raising, education, the media and the training of professionals. It also establishes the obligation to base protection and support measures, as well as investigations and judicial proceedings, on an understanding of gender-based violence. The concept of gender therefore runs deep throughout the Convention.
Migrant women, whether documented or undocumented, and women seeking asylum are particularly vulnerable to gender-based violence. Although the reasons why they leave their country and their legal status vary greatly, both groups face an increased risk of violence and similar difficulties in responding to it. That is why the Convention prohibits using migrant or refugee status as a pretext for any discrimination in the implementation of its provisions. It also calls for measures to prevent this violence and to support victims, taking into account the needs of vulnerable people.
The Convention also devotes an entire chapter to migrant and asylum-seeking women facing gender-based violence against women. It contains a number of obligations aimed at adopting a gender-sensitive understanding of violence against migrant and asylum-seeking women. For example, it introduces the possibility of granting migrant women who are victims of domestic violence, and whose residence status depends on that of their spouse or partner, an independent residence permit when the relationship ends. This allows the victim to leave the relationship without losing her residence status. It also creates, for example, an obligation to allow migrant victims who, because of a forced marriage in another country, have left the country to which they had immigrated and not returned, to regain their residence status.
In addition, the chapter contains provisions setting out the obligation to recognise gender-based violence against women as a form of persecution within the meaning of the 1951 Refugee Convention, and the obligation to ensure a gender-sensitive interpretation in the refugee status determination process.
It is important to note that the protection problems faced by women seeking asylum are different from those faced by men. In particular, women may be fleeing gender-based violence but are often unable or reluctant to disclose relevant information during a refugee status determination process. In addition, unaccompanied women are often exposed to sexual harassment and exploitation and are unable to protect themselves. To address the specific problems of women seeking asylum, the Convention sets out the obligation to introduce gender-sensitive asylum procedures, guidelines and support services. Introducing a gender perspective into procedures makes it possible to take account of the differences between women and men.
Another provision of the Convention reiterates the obligation to respect a well-established principle of asylum and international refugee protection: non-refoulement. The Convention requires States to ensure that victims of violence against women who need protection, regardless of their status or residence, are not returned to a country where their life could be at risk or where they could be subjected to torture or inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.
In many member States, the vast majority of services for victims of domestic violence, and those for victims of sexual violence, stalking, forced marriage and other forms of violence, are run by non-governmental or civil society organisations. These organisations have a long tradition of providing shelters, legal advice and medical and psychological counselling. They also run helplines and other essential services. However, many of these services have uncertain funding and only operate in small geographical areas. In most countries, the overall number of services available does not meet victims' needs, often because providing services is not seen as a necessity but as a voluntary activity of NGOs.
That is why the Convention recognises the work of NGOs and calls for them to receive stronger political and financial support. Some of its provisions require the Parties to encourage and support the work of NGOs by drawing on their expertise, involving them as partners in multi-agency cooperation and supporting their awareness-raising initiatives. Measures to prevent and combat violence against women and domestic violence can thus achieve better results. Supporting NGOs and civil society organisations helps to make their work more effective, for example by setting up cooperative structures between law enforcement and shelters, by better promoting their helplines and services in government information materials, and by ensuring adequate public and political support for them. The Convention also requires the Parties to allocate sufficient financial and human resources to the activities of non-governmental and civil society organisations.
Finally, NGOs will also play a role in monitoring the implementation of the Convention. The group of experts responsible for monitoring may receive information from NGOs on a Party's implementation of the Convention, in addition to the information provided by the Party itself.
Exposure to violence and to physical, sexual or psychological abuse has serious consequences for children. It causes fear and trauma and has harmful effects on their development. Violence against women and domestic violence, in their direct or indirect forms, can have dangerous consequences for their health and their lives. In the case of domestic violence, it is recognised that children do not need to be directly affected to be considered victims, because witnessing violence is just as traumatic.
The Convention covers various forms of violence against women and domestic violence. The victims are generally girls and women of all ages. However, boys and men can also be victims of certain types of violence that fall within the scope of the Convention, in particular domestic violence and forced marriage. That is why States are encouraged to extend the measures recommended by the Convention to boys and men.
In addition, several provisions expressly concern children. They ask States to take the following measures:
In the field of prevention:
– promote and run awareness-raising campaigns on the different manifestations of all forms of violence against women and domestic violence and their consequences for children.
– develop and promote, in cooperation with the private sector, the skills of children, parents and educators to deal with violent and harmful content in communication spaces.
– ensure that preventive measures take into account the specific needs of child victims.
In the field of protection and support
– provide specialist support services for women victims of sexual violence and their children. Provide safe accommodation for women and their children.
– ensure that the rights and needs of child witnesses are taken into account in protection and support measures for victims.
In the field of prosecution:
– criminalise intentionally forcing a child to marry, or luring a child to another country in order to force them into marriage.
– ensure that criminal law covers inciting a child to commit so-called honour crimes.
– ensure that child victims and child witnesses benefit from special protection measures at all stages of the investigation and judicial proceedings.